Much Ado About Nothing: nicely sums up Reyes’ departure in the 1st inning of the Mets’ final game of the season.
Reyes exited the game in the 1st inning with a .337 batting average after his bunt single and sending a message to Mr. Braun saying, if you want to win the batting race then beat that!
A few hours later Mr. Braun answered with an 0 for 4 evening at the plate finishing the season 5 thousandths of a percentage point behind Reyes with a.332 average.
However, everyone thought it was criminal that Reyes exited the final game in the 1st inning after his bunt single. The fans wanted to see Reyes play the entire game, which could have been his last at bat as a Met, and the media wanted to see Reyes compete to his last at bat for the batting title .
People were comparing Reyes’ exit of the game to Ted Williams’ resolve of playing in a double-header on the last day of the season in 1941 which saw Williams go 6 for 8 and raised his batting average from a .400 to .406 making him the last man in MLB to hit .400!
First of all, the two events are like comparing apples and oranges! Williams was not competing against anyone for a batting title. Williams was competing against himself.
Williams’ coach told him that he could sit out the double-header and still hit .400 for the season. Williams would have none of that and demanded that he play in both games. Williams had already won the batting title since DiMaggio’s .357 was a whopping 33 points behind Williams’ .400 going into the last day of the ’41 season.
So how can Williams and Reyes be compared? They can’t! The two events aren’t even remotely close. Williams had already won the batting title for the season where as Reyes was in a battle for the batting title.
Furthermore, baseball contracts of today are incentive laden and winning batting titles, all-star appearances and even plate appearances command big dollars for today’s players.
Jose Reyes did what any baseball player of today’s ilk would have done especially when the player has a team of agents in his ear advising him what he needs to do to secure the pot of gold and lines the agent’s pockets as well.
Simply put, all Reyes did was compete for the batting title, the best he could, to the very last day of the season and then he laid out his cards on the table and said to Mr. Braun, here’s my hand let’s see if you can beat that! To which Braun, simply, folded.
Here’s a recap of the final week of hitting for Reyes and Braun. I think the figures and facts clearly bear out the strategy of both players and illustrates that the batting title winner rose to the occasion.
Monday 26 September 2011
On Monday morning Braun was leading the batting title race with a .333 average. Jose was only hitting .331.
However, on Monday night with only 4 games left to play in the season and home field advantage on the line for the Brewers, the umpires received the line-up card without Braun’s name on it. That’s right, Braun chose to sit out Monday night’s game with his leading .333 average.
Yes, that is correct, Braun was leading Reyes in the National League batting title, but he chose to sit out Monday’s game with the lead.
Jose Reyes, on the other hand, chose to play in Monday night’s game when the Mets were playing for absolutely nothing. Reyes seized the opportunity going 3 for 4 and raised his average from .331 to .334.
Ryan Braun did not play on Monday night, however when Reyes went 3-4 and raised his .331 trailing average to a .334 leading average Braun was then inserted into Monday night’s game as a pinch hitter. In his pinch-hit at bat Braun answered the bell and doubled which raised his trailing average of .333 to a tying average of .334.
In summary, Braun sat out Monday night’s game with his leading batting average and waited to see what Reyes would do. When Reyes surpassed him Braun then entered the game in an effort to keep pace in the race.
Tuesday 27 September 2011
Braun and Reyes tied at .334.
Braun goes 1 for 2 raising his average to .335.
Reyes goes 3 for 6 with 2 home-runs in 13 innings and raised his average to .336.
In Reyes’ first 4 at bats he went 3 for 4 and he could have taken himself out of this game with his .338 average, but he played all 13 innings when the Mets were still playing for absolutely nothing.
Wednesday 28 September 2011
Reyes’ average: .336
Braun’s average: .335
Wednesday was the final game of the regular season for both teams, but the Mets were playing a day game and the Brewers were playing a night game. This meant that Braun would know exactly what Reyes did in his game and exactly what he needed to do to win the batting title before the Brewers’ game even started that night.
The time difference in the two games prompted reports to ask Braun if he would play in his game if Reyes’ average fell below Braun’s average.
Braun said that the Brewers are still playing for something. He said the Brewers are playing for home field, so he said that he will play no matter what happens with Reyes.
My question to Braun is, what happened on Monday night when he was leading the batting title race? Why didn’t he play then? His team was still playing for something on Monday, in fact, his team lost Monday’s game. Who knows if the Brewers would have won Monday’s game if Braun played, but his statement on Wednesday certainly does not reconcile with his actions on the previous Monday.
So going into Wednesday’s game Jose Reyes was leading the batting race with a .336 average while Braun was not far behind with a .335, only 1 thousandths of a percentage point separated Reyes and Braun.
In true Jose Reyes fashion he rose to the occasion and got a hit in his first at bat and decided that was good enough to win the race and took himself out of the game. With his .337 batting average Reyes sent a message to Mr. Braun that Braun would have to be better than his best to beat Reyes today. In fact, Braun would have to go 3 for 4 or better to win the batting title.
The Brewers ended up beating the Pirates 7-3 on Wednesday night, but Braun went 0-4 and finished his season with a batting average of .332.
Sure we would have all loved to see Reyes play the complete game en route to the Met’s first batting title winner. However, in 2011 the national league batting title came down to two players battling it out to the very last day or in this case night.
To win any game or competition sound strategy is paramount. Monday night Braun employed his strategy and on Wednesday night Reyes employed his. When the dust settled Reyes’ strategy and average won the race fair and square.
Well done Jose!